By Benjamin Hanson
If you’re exploring Stillwater’s restaurant scene lately, there are a few spots worth your attention: Feller, Matchstick Restaurant & Spirits, and the newly opened E’s Gourmet Sandwiches downtown. Each offers something unique for different moods and occasions.
Feller: Elevated Comfort in a Modern Setting
Located at 402 South Main Street inside the Lora hotel, Feller blends rustic charm with elevated fare. Guests often praise its imaginative menu—dishes like venison strip loin, morel fettuccine, and halibut are crafted with care and presented beautifully. On the beverage side, the cocktail program and wine list complement the food well. With prices in the $$-range, it leans upscale—but many reviews say the value lines up when you get exceptional flavors, especially from appetizers or signature entrees. Service is generally warm and attentive, though some mention it slipping during peak hours. The atmosphere makes it a favorite for celebrations or nights out when you want something more special.
Matchstick Restaurant & Spirits: Farm-to-Table with Flair
Matchstick, at 232 North Main Street, offers a menu built around locally sourced meats and fish, prepared using wood-fire techniques. The small plates here are shareable, hearty, and often bold in flavor. Reviewers love the wings, brisket, and standout sides like Brussels sprouts. Cocktails are creative, and the rustic yet refined setting adds to the overall experience. It’s ideal for dinner with friends or date nights. Note that portions and pricing can vary—some feel that certain dishes are small for the cost, but many return for the food, ambiance, and drink selections. Reservations are available, making it easier to plan ahead for busy evenings.
E’s Gourmet Sandwiches: A Local Bite with Heart
For something more casual but still thoughtfully done, E’s Gourmet Sandwiches has opened in downtown Stillwater. Run by a young local entrepreneur, the shop offers handhelds like fried chicken sandwiches, Reubens, smash burgers, and cold-cut clubs. It’s a great spot for lunch, quick dinner, or a picnic near the river. The space leans simple, which fits the concept—here, the focus is on flavor over frills. Expect solid value and approachability, especially compared to the more formal places in town.
Best Picks Depending on What You’re After
- Looking for a special occasion or romantic dinner? Go to Feller, especially a corner booth with its Main Street view.
- Craving bold, shareable plates and craft drinks? Matchstick is your spot.
- Just want something quick, tasty, and unpretentious? E’s Gourmet Sandwiches hits the mark.
Stillwater’s dining scene is growing richer—varied in price and style—making it easier to match your mood, hunger level, and company. Whether you want elegant or easygoing, one or all of these should be on your go-to list.