Stillwater’s food scene continues to blossom, blending longtime favorites with bold new arrivals. Here’s a look at some of the restaurants locals are talking about, including must-try meals, memorable spaces, and what’s creating buzz around town.
New Eats Shaping the Town
E’s Gourmet Sandwiches (221 E. Myrtle St.)
Launched by a 20-year-old entrepreneur, this spot delivers all the hallmarks of a great casual shop: smash burgers, Reubens, fried chicken sandwiches and inventive sides. The small space is leveraged well, with friendly service and a clear eye on flavor that beats typical deli fare. If you’re hungry for something familiar but elevated, this is it. Open for picnic season, but worth a visit anytime.
Xela’s by El Sazón
This contemporary Latin restaurant on the West Frontage Road stands out with a polished menu, flavorful presentations, and outstanding service. Fans rave about generous drinks, masterful seasoning, and the energy of its dining room. A great choice if you’re looking for something special for dinner—that’s relaxed, but doesn’t hold back on ambition.
Feller
Located in Lora, the first new hotel in Stillwater built in more than two decades, Feller spans breakfast through dinner daily. It’s farmhouse-meets-modern-comfort using seasonal ingredients, all set inside a former brewery built into the bluff. Whether you’re in for brunch, lunch or dinner, the vibe—historic setting, smart plates—is a strong draw.
Longstanding Local Gems Worth Revisiting
Phil’s Tara Hideaway
A log-cabin style restaurant just off Highway 36, it’s been cherished by locals for its warm, intimate atmosphere, attentive service, and a menu that meshes Greek flavors with classic American comforts. It feels timeless, but still manages to surprise with dishes that keep people coming back.
Domaćin Restaurant, Lounge & Wine Shop
Refined yet approachable, Domaćin offers thoughtful pairings of New American cuisine with wines you won’t find everywhere else. Expect attention to detail—fresh seafood, careful plating, and desserts that linger. It’s the kind of place for a date, a celebration, or any night when you want something just a little more elevated.
Leo’s Grill & Malt Shop
A breakfast, lunch, and diner staple. Burgers, kettled chips, chocolate malts, friendly faces. If comfort food is what you’re after—and nostalgia with it—Leo’s still delivers in spades.
Where to Go from Here
For everyday dining or a quick snack, try these ideas:
- Check the menus at Matchstick Restaurant & Spirits for seafood-forward dishes and creative cocktails in a lively pub-bar setting.
- Brick & Bourbon remains one of the best bets for BBQ-inspired fare and craft drinks.
- Grab brunch or a casual bite at Oasis Cafe or dive into baked-good stalls around town for sweet and savory treats.
No matter your appetite, Stillwater offers a rich mix—casual and formal, traditional and inventive. There’s always something worth trying next.